Thursday, March 31, 2022

Sizing up Shiurim: Modern-Day Measuring—Up or Down?

Another contemporary posek, Rav Chaim Na’eh (early 20th century), extensively researched the matter, and among other calculations, based his measurements on the weight of a certain dirham (mid-Eastern coin)—a tradition going back in time to the Rambam (12th century early halachic authority). He reached an opposite conclusion: we should downsize our shiurim based on the current physical reality. Rav Chaim Na’eh’s revi’is measures 86.4 ml. At that time in Yerushalayim (where Rav Chaim was rav), this shiur was universally accepted. Today it is the common shiur in most of the world, and the Chazon Ish shiur is categorized as an extra chumrah (stringency).

1 comment :

  1. The Chazon Ish, was a great innovator, although in a chareidi/machmir manner.
    Chareidism is an innovation too - but it claims to be against innovation.
    Even the Chatam Sofer's "hadash assur min haTorah" was a chiddush - the verse refers to new grain (new season's grain is forbidden until the Omer ceremony every year) - was aimed at Reform who wanted to change the siddur and shul ceremonies. It became a fixation and was applied later to every modern development in the world.


please use either your real name or a pseudonym.