Shomer Emunim HaKadmon (1:13): It is quite obvious to us and is clearly stated in the gemora and medrash in many places that there is a power to names and amulets to do amazing things …. Nevertheless, the Rambam denies that this is true and strongly ridicules those who believe in the power of names to do anything. We see this in Moreh Nevuchim . Thus, he does not find the testimony of the gemora credible. It is also known that our Sages received traditions concerning demons and witchcraft as is well known from the gemora and medrashim. Nevertheless, the Rambam decided that they are nonsense and stupidity and that all who believe that they are real but the Torah has prohibited them is a fool and idiot and is included amongst the ignorant women and children.. Even though the issue of magic is mentioned in the Torah itself in a number of places - nevertheless the rationalists reject their validity and produce far-fetched explanations to these verses in order not to violate their rationalism. They are not concerned with the words of our Sages that are clearly stated in a number of places which clearly acknowledge the reality of demons and magic. Their rejection of these things is that according to the rationalistic understanding it is simply impossible that these things exist. This is the approach of the rationalists. They will simply not accept the validity of anything said by our Sages which contradicts rational human understanding…
Why is the Shomer Emunim Hakadmon objecting to a sensible position?
ReplyDeleteThe Gra said something similar.
ReplyDeleteNevertheless, the Rambam is a great enough authority to decide what is taken literally and what is not.
Just because the Torah mentions magic doesn't mean tht magic is real. The point is not to practice it or rely on those who do, probably because it's fake and provides insincere results.
ReplyDeleteAfter all, there's a reason the witch of Endor (the place, not the moon the Death Star II was orbiting) was shocked when Shmuel's ghost appeared. It was the first time her tricks actually worked.
How was it "quite obvious"?
ReplyDeleteRabbi Yosef Ergas lived from 1685–1730. According to
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence-based_medicine
"The concept of a controlled clinical trial was first described in 1662 by Jan Baptist van Helmont" While his proposed experiment wouldn't have passed the ethics committee today, and didn't include double-blinding or a control group, he did have the idea of randomly dividing patients and testing different treatments.
Yesterday in shul, we had a lecture after kiddush by an astrophysicist who proposed the Gemara on Pesachim 94b, comparing the view of Jewish and non-Jewish wise people about the path of the Sun at night and Rebbi's preferring the later due to evidence as an early version of the scientific method, although it does seem to be imagining the non-Jewish view to be the Sun going below a flat earth, warming the springs, rather than being on the other side of a globe whose size had been measured and was too large for the Sun's warmth to travel through a sphere of circumference of 250,000 to 252,000 stadia