Tamar burns the bridge, and her poor daughter's future. It won't be easy going through life being called a Mamzer. Just wait for the tumult to erupt in some 20 years from now, when she wants to start shidduchim...
She might marry someone from her community, and the Mesader Kiddushin could be the rabbi from the shul where the Fleischers attend. He obviously doesn't have a problem with their sham marriage.
I'm not pursuing the Mamzeres. Her adulterous parents saddled her with this terrible burden, and sadly, the truth will pursue her. The blog owner, is merely publicizing information that the public needs to know.
I don't know which brand of Judaism you're referring to. There is an entire tractate of the Talmud, called Horiyot, which is predicated on the assumption that even members of the ancient Sanhedrin, the greatest Rabbis of the generation, were capable of erring, even in halachic matters.
Tamar burns the bridge, and her poor daughter's future. It won't be easy going through life being called a Mamzer. Just wait for the tumult to erupt in some 20 years from now, when she wants to start shidduchim...
ReplyDeleteSo you plan to harass a newborn baby who doesn't know right from wrong for the next 20 years?
ReplyDeleteI don't plan on harassing her, but things have a way of happening.
DeleteSad story. This baby is a victim of her parent's indifference.
It just means she will likely be forced to intermarry or get into open conservadoxy...
DeleteShe might marry someone from her community, and the Mesader Kiddushin could be the rabbi from the shul where the Fleischers attend. He obviously doesn't have a problem with their sham marriage.
DeleteWhat motivates you to pursue this poor little b-stard child?
DeleteIs it your love of humanity or something else?
I'm not pursuing the Mamzeres.
DeleteHer adulterous parents saddled her with this terrible burden, and sadly, the truth will pursue her.
The blog owner, is merely publicizing information that the public needs to know.
KA you obviously prefer that your family and community be surprised!
DeletePhilly community, or conservadox... Not mine.
DeleteSufficient number of people accept R N G, so his psak has some validity....
ReplyDeleteAccording to your acceptance theory
https://jewishaction.com/cover-story/rabbi-nota-greenblatt-ztl/
But he didn't pasken he said assuming the facts are as stated but the facts he was told were wrong
DeleteWasn't it the other way around.?
DeleteDidn't you say he held his psak to still be a psak since he paskened it?
He said it was important to accept the words of gedolim without questioning their truth
DeleteReferring to himself..
DeleteZakein Hador who made a big mistake, at best.
ReplyDeleteJudaism doesn't believe in Papal infallibility.
Well actually it does. It's just a question of whom you hold to be infallible. It's always the other group who err, not yet chosen Daas Torah group
ReplyDeleteI don't know which brand of Judaism you're referring to.
ReplyDeleteThere is an entire tractate of the Talmud, called Horiyot, which is predicated on the assumption that even members of the ancient Sanhedrin, the greatest Rabbis of the generation, were capable of erring, even in halachic matters.
Correct, I agree 💯
ReplyDeleteBut hareidim have either never heard of it, or if they have they think it's been superceded by modern Daas Torah