I was recently asked in a Face Book discussion about the guidelines I use for reporting abuse cases. The issue was whether a particularly horrific case involving allegations of incest, gang rape and torture should be published. I decided not to publish it at present. I was asked why I view this case differently than the Weberman and Kolko cases which also involved allegations but which I have extensive reporting? I thought it might be useful to publish here my response to the question.
I
don't automatically put a news item on my blog just because it involves
accusations of abuse - it involves a judgment as to the costs vs
benefits. In the case of Kolko and Weberman - I had additional reports
from those I consider reliable that the charges were valid and more
important that significant pressure was being applied to have the
charges dropped. Therefore there was a major need to counterbalance the
community pressure in these cases. A case that is widely covered in the
secular press is generally also reported to avoid the impression of
cover up. A situation where there are multiple victims is also reported
in order to encourage reporting to the police. In situations where the
perpetrator has escaped - I generally report it so hopefully he will get
caught. Cases that illustrate that the abuser is often a respected or
beloved individual is also reported in order to break down the
stereotype that a crazy stranger is the abuser. In the present case -
there was a single accuser, no indication that there was any evidence or
that she was viewed as trustworthy. More important the details reported
were especially horrific. I could not find other news sources that were
reporting it. I could not think of an obvious benefit to publishing
this anonymous case and the negative consequences of publicizing it are
obvious. I often - though not always - publicize convictions so that
people understand that abuse is not a rare event. There is also the
issue of balance - I don't want to simply report all the negative items
about our community - people stop reading the items or assume that is all
that is going on in the world. in fact I will also publicize related
articles from outside our community if it helps provide a context for
abuse - such as the Penn State scandal or the Catholic Church