Monday, March 4, 2024

Parnossa does not interfere with Torah Learning

 Ruach Chaim (5:05) One of the ten miracles that occurred in the Temple was that the rain did not put out the fire burning on the wood for the sacrifices... The claim of most people is that in our times it is not possible to be fully engaged in Torah study because of the concern and effort to earn a living. To this he is responding that this is absolutely wrong! Rather a person needs to have bitachon in G-d that he will be able to engage fully in Torah study. This that it says that the rains will not extinguish the fire is a a metaphor for parnossa, In other words there will be no loss by fully engaging in Torah study which is comparable to fire. 

Ruach Chaim (Avos 1:14) He used to say If I am not for myself who will be for me?  You should know that the yetzer harah blinds the eyes of a person by saying constantly to him “How can you be involved in Torah study since it is required to earn a living for the sake of your wife and children especially at the present time when the burden of earning a living is extremely heavy, While that in truth is the blinding advice of the evil inclination. In reality our Sages tell us that before the baby is formed it has already been decreed whether he will be rich or poor and this is typically for his entire life. Furthermore on each individual year it is decreed from Rosh Hashanna what wealth he will receive. Therefore all his efforts will not get for him more than has been decreed and in fact he will get his portion with minimal effort. In contrast his accomplishment in Torah is proportional to his effort. Thus the Mishna is saying regarding Torah If I am not for myself who will be for me? That is because It all depends on me. In contrast the Mishna continues that regarding this world if I rely totally on myself than what am I 

Rambam (Hilchos Shemitta 13:12–13): Why didn’t the tribe of Levi merit an inheritance in the land of Israel as well as the spoils of war like the other tribes? It is because they were given the responsibility to serve G d and to teach His righteous ways to the masses… Therefore they were separated from the ways of world and were not involved in war like the rest of Israel and they neither inherited nor obtained things by means of physical endeavors. They were G d’s army and G d provided for them. However, this way of life is not exclusively for the tribe of Levi but in fact any person in the world whose spirit moves him. He understands by himself to separate and stand before G d to serve Him in order to know G d. If he goes in the upright path, as G d desired then the yoke of constant worry characteristic of mankind will be taken from him. He will be sanctified, as holy of holies and G d will be his portion and inheritance forever. He will consequently obtain in this world that which he needs in the same way as the Cohanim and Leviim…

4 comments :

  1. Everyone loves to quote that Rambam while forgetting that the Kohanim and Levi'im had to go around to the granaries to pick up their "gifts", had to grind and bake the bread themselves, had to engage in commerce with their "gifts" to support themselves.
    Today's wanna-be "I'm a kli kodesh" expect donors to show up at their door holding lots of money.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Source for what? That the kohanim and levi'im had to go around to get their own stuff from the farmers? You, of all people, are asking me for sources from that?
      The only stuff brought directly to the priests in Jerusalem were bikurim.

      Delete
    2. I wish to raise a problem - are Rabbis of the Haredi persuasion bribed by their reliance on donations, ie they do not get involved in the real world of work - do not have to write CVs, apply for jobs in a hostile world, be rejected by goyim or other hiring managers,
      do not have to commute, and work for corporations to make ends meet etc etc.
      Such people, even if they are "Gedolim" academically, are a0 bribed, and b) disqualified from offering any daas or psak when it comes to ordinary baalabatish people

      Delete

ANONYMOUS COMMENTS WILL NOT BE POSTED!
please use either your real name or a pseudonym.