Pele Yoetz (Daughter):
I have seen a terrible custom
in some places that when a daughter is born that the people make a lot of jokes
and ridicule it. One person says, “The cold is great” and another ones say, “The
smell is overwhelming”. This type of “humor” is openly expressed until the
person who just had a daughter born cannot find a place to hide from those
pursuing after him with ridicule and jokes. This custom is totally disgusting
to me and they violate the verse in Mishlei (17:5), “One who ridicules the poor
has blasphemed his Creator.” That
is because it one of the hidden matters as to why G‑d gives sons to whom He
wants and daughters to whom he wants. Consequently one who ridicules the birth
of a daughter is speaking against G‑d and well as transgressing the serious prohibition
against mocking others. But there is something even more stupid and nonsensical
than ridiculing the birth of a daughter. There are some insensitive and
ignorant people that when their wife gives birth to a son they express love to
her and greatly honor her. In contrast if she gives birth to a girl, they avoid
her and basically abandon her – not even to see her. How great must be his wife’s sense of
alienation and grief! These are truly foolish people. What does he want from
his wife? Did she go to the market to choose to buy him a daughter and not a
son? Furthermore what
business does he have criticizing the private decisions of G‑d? Perhaps
daughters are better for him then sons because of their mazel and their lot. We
have personally witnessed fathers who have rejoiced equally for their daughters
and sons and yet their daughters’ portion in life was more blessed than that of
sons. Woe is it to the man whose sons’ accomplishments are more appropriate for
daughters and even worse than daughters in their ignorance because in fact
there are a great number of ignoramuses and true scholars are few. Great are
the pains of the father of sons when they don’t make a name for themselves in
Torah learning and service of G‑d. In contrast the highest goals for daughters
are more readily accomplished since it is primarily to teach them an occupation
and proper character.
Bava Basra (16b):A daughter was born to Rav Shimon the son of
Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi and he was upset because of it. His father tried to comfort
him by saying, Increase has come to the world. Bar Kappara said to him, Your
father has tried comforting you with a worthless consolation. Because the
braissa says, The world can not exist without both males or females and yet
happy is he whose children are males and woe is he whose children are females.
Similarly the world cannot exist without both spice sellers or tanners, and yet
happy is he whose profession is that of a spice seller and woe is he whose
professions is that of tanner. On this issue of the value of daughters there is
a dispute amongst the Tannaim. It says in Bereishis (24:1), G‑d blessed Avraham
with everything [ba-kol]. What is meant by the word “everything”? R’ Meir said
it means he was blessed with not having a daughter. R’ Yehuda said it means he
was blessed with a daughter. Others (Acherim) say it means that he had a
daughter whose name was “everything” (ba-kol).
Bava Basra(141a): For R. Hisda said: [If a] daughter [is born] first, it is a good sign for the children. Some say, because she rears her brothers; and others say. because the evil eye has no influence over them. R. Hisda said: To me, however, daughters are dearer than sons.
Bava Basra(141a): For R. Hisda said: [If a] daughter [is born] first, it is a good sign for the children. Some say, because she rears her brothers; and others say. because the evil eye has no influence over them. R. Hisda said: To me, however, daughters are dearer than sons.
שב שמעתתא (הקדמה ע' כא): ואפשר בזה רמזו בש"ס בבא בתרא ד' קמא ע"א בת תחילה סימן יפה לבנים דרבה לאחהא עפ"י מ"ש באבות כל שיראתו קודמת לחכמתו כו', וכל שחכמתו קודמת ליראת חטאו כוו וזהו בת
תחלה היינו היראה סימן יפה לבנים היית תורה דרבי' ילבנהא, דע" י היראה
התורה מתקיימת
Pardes Yosef (Bereishis
24:1):
The Torah Temima (Bereishis
24:1.6) writes that in Menachos (43b) it states that Rav Meir decreed saying
the beracha “Who has not made me a woman” and this is consistent with his view
that a daughter is not a blessing. Rabbi Yehuda added that even though a son is
a greater blessing than a daughter – that is only for someone who has a son.
However someone who has a son also desires to have a daughter. Also the mitzva
of having children is fulfilled only by having both a son and daughter. Others
(Acherim) added that complete happeniness is only when the children go in the
upright path. We know concerning Yitzchok that is says in Bereishis (25:19)
that Yitzchok was the son of Avraham and that Avraham had a child Yitzchok.
This verse tells you that all the fine qualities that existed in Avraham also
existed in Yitzchok. However when it talks about the qualities of the daught
the Torah doesn’t mention them. It simply says according to Acherim that the
daughters name was ba-chol in the say one would say that a particular person
has all the fine qualities. And thus he understands that Avaraham happiness was
complete since he had a daughter with all the fine qualities.
Berachos(5b): And that my bed should be placed north and south. For R. Hama b. R. Hanina said in the name of R. Isaac: Whosoever places his bed north and south will have male children, as it says: And whose belly Thou fillest with Thy treasure, who have sons in plenty. R. Nahman b. Isaac says: His wife also will not miscarry. Here it is written: And whose belly Thou fillest with Thy treasure, and elsewhere it is written: And when her days to be delivered were fulfilled, behold there were twins in her womb.
Berachos(5b): And that my bed should be placed north and south. For R. Hama b. R. Hanina said in the name of R. Isaac: Whosoever places his bed north and south will have male children, as it says: And whose belly Thou fillest with Thy treasure, who have sons in plenty. R. Nahman b. Isaac says: His wife also will not miscarry. Here it is written: And whose belly Thou fillest with Thy treasure, and elsewhere it is written: And when her days to be delivered were fulfilled, behold there were twins in her womb.
Sanhedrin(100b): R. Joseph said: it is also forbidden to read the book of Ben Sira. Abaye said to him: Why so? Shall we say because there is written therein, ... A daughter is a vain treasure to her father: through anxiety on her account, he cannot sleep at night. As a minor, lest she be seduced; in her majority, lest she play the harlot; as an adult, lest she be not married; if she marries, lest she bear no children; if she grows old, lest she engage in witchcraft! But the Rabbis have said the same: The world cannot exist without males and females; happy is he whose children are males, and woe to him whose children are females.
Berachos(60a): Within the first three days a man should pray that the seed should not putrefy; from the third to the fortieth day he should pray that the child should be a male; from the fortieth day to three months he should pray that it should not be a sandal; from three months to six months he should pray that it should not be still-born; from six months to nine months he should pray for a safe delivery.
Nida (31b): R. Isaac citing R. Ammi further stated: As soon as a male comes into the world peace comes into the world, for it is said, Send ye a gift for the ruler of the land [and the Hebrew for] male [is composed of the consonants of the words for] this is a giftR. Isaac citing16 R. Ammi further stated: When a male comes into the world his provision comes with him, [the Hebrew for] male [zakar, being composed of the consonants of the words for] this is provision [zeh kar],for it is written, And he prepared a great provision [kera] for them. A female has nothing with her, [the Hebrew for] female [nekebah] implying she comes with nothing [nekiyyah ba'ah]. Unless she demands her food nothing is given to her, for it is written, Demand [nakebah] from me thy wages and I will give it
Berachos(60a): Within the first three days a man should pray that the seed should not putrefy; from the third to the fortieth day he should pray that the child should be a male; from the fortieth day to three months he should pray that it should not be a sandal; from three months to six months he should pray that it should not be still-born; from six months to nine months he should pray for a safe delivery.
Nida (31b): R. Isaac citing R. Ammi further stated: As soon as a male comes into the world peace comes into the world, for it is said, Send ye a gift for the ruler of the land [and the Hebrew for] male [is composed of the consonants of the words for] this is a giftR. Isaac citing16 R. Ammi further stated: When a male comes into the world his provision comes with him, [the Hebrew for] male [zakar, being composed of the consonants of the words for] this is provision [zeh kar],for it is written, And he prepared a great provision [kera] for them. A female has nothing with her, [the Hebrew for] female [nekebah] implying she comes with nothing [nekiyyah ba'ah]. Unless she demands her food nothing is given to her, for it is written, Demand [nakebah] from me thy wages and I will give it
Throughout generations the favoritism towards sons is for employment or yeshiva heirship, plus a continuation of the namesake.
ReplyDeleteIf you had a POLL among families, the answer might be a surprise.
RDE: You may wish to quote the Gemorah that advises people how to have a son rather than a daughter.
ReplyDeleteThat Gemorah seems to clearly indicate sons are more desirable than daughters.
I believe the Gemorah explains the best sexual position to help conceive a son rather than a daughter.
ReplyDeleteDon't agree with your understanding of the gemora - it doesn't say you should do it.
DeleteBerachos (5b) And that my bed should be placed north and south. For R. Hama b. R. Hanina said in the name of R. Isaac: Whosoever places his bed north and south will have male children, as it says: And whose belly Thou fillest with Thy treasure,23 who have sons in plenty.24 R. Nahman b. Isaac says: His wife also will not miscarry. Here it is written: And whose belly Thou fillest with Thy treasure, and elsewhere it is written: And when her days to be delivered were fulfilled, behold there were twins in her womb.25
Clearly the Gemorah is providing this information because a male child is preferable. That is the only reason the Gemorah advises how to have a male child rather than a female.
DeleteThe Gemorah also says that if a wife truly loves her husband, her first child will be a boy.
DeleteThe Gemorah opens saying "And that my bed should be placed north and south..." because "...Whosoever places his bed north and south will have male children".
DeleteSo clearly the Gemorah is saying that he wants male children.
The gemora simply is describing a technique - it follows that if his bed is placed in a different orientation he will more likely have girls. In contrast the gemora in BB 149a explicity says that girls are preferable.
DeleteAre there any studies confirming the correlation between bed orientation and gendr of children?
DeleteIf we do not believe this correlation is real, are we apikorsim?
I vaguely remember Kitzur shulchan aruch stating that having a girl is not a particular joy, as opposed to having a boy...
DeleteRDE: I think you should also quote the Gemorah that says that if a wife truly loves her husband, her first child will be male, as it fits into the category we are discussing here.
ReplyDelete