Sunday, April 3, 2022

Rambam rejects Chazal because he was a rationalist

 Shomer Emunim HaKadmon (1:13): It is quite obvious to us and is clearly stated in the gemora and medrash in many places that there is a power to names and amulets to do amazing things e.g., Shabbos (61a) and Yevamos (49b)…Rashba (1:220). Nevertheless, the Rambam denies that this is true and strongly ridicules those who believe in the power of names to do anything. We see this in Moreh Nevuchim (1:61–62). Thus, he does not find the testimony of the gemora credible. It is also known that our Sages received traditions concerning demons and witchcraft as is well known from the gemora and medrashim. Nevertheless, the Rambam decided that they are nonsense and stupidity and that all who believe that they are real but the Torah has prohibited them is a fool and idiot and is included amongst the ignorant women and children (Hilchos Avoda Zara 11:16)... Even though the issue of magic is mentioned in the Torah itself in a number of places - nevertheless the rationalists reject their validity and produce far-fetched explanations to these verses in order not to violate their rationalism. They are not concerned with the words of our Sages that are clearly stated in a number of places which clearly acknowledge the reality of demons and magic. Their rejection of these things is that according to the rationalistic understanding it is simply impossible that these things exist. This is the approach of the rationalists. They will simply not accept the validity of anything said by our Sages which contradicts rational human understanding…

Rambam (Tefilin 5:4) It is a universal custom to write the word Shaddai (Almighty) on the other side of the Mezuzah, opposite the blank space between the two sections. As this word is written on the outside, the practice is unobjectionable. They, however, who write names of angels, holy names, a Biblical text or inscriptions usual on seals, within the Mezuzah, are among those who have no portion in the world to come. For these fools not only fail to fulfill the commandment but they treat an important precept that expresses the Unity of God, the love of Him, and His worship, as if it were an amulet to promote their own personal interests; for, according to their foolish minds, the Mezuzah is something that will secure for them advantage in the vanities of the world.*A reproof to those who sell Mezuzoth to be worn as amulets ! 

Avoda Zara (11a) When Onkelos the son of Kalonymus became a proselyte, the Emperor sent a contingent of Roman soldiers after him, but he enticed them by citing scriptural verses and they became converted to Judaism. Thereupon, the Emperor sent another Roman cohort after him, bidding them not to say anything to him. As they were about to take him away with them, he said to them: ‘Let me tell you just an ordinary thing: In a procession the torchlighter carries the light in front of the torchbearer, the torchbearer in front of the leader, the leader in front of the governor, the governor in front of the chief officer; but does the chief officer carry the light in front of the people that follow?’ ‘No!’ they replied. Said he: ‘Yet the Holy One, blessed be He, does carry the light before Israel, for Scripture says. And the Lord went before them . . . in a pillar of fire to give them light.’ Then they, too, became converted. Again he sent another cohort ordering them not to enter into any conversation whatever with him. So they took hold of him; and as they were walking on he saw the mezuzah which was fixed on the door-frame and he placed his hand on it saying to them: ‘Now what is this?’ and they replied: ‘You tell us then.’ Said he, ‘According to universal custom, the mortal king dwells within, and his servants keep guard on him without; but in the case of the Holy One, blessed be He, it is His servants who dwell within whilst He keeps guard on them from without; as it is said: The Lord shall guard thy going out and thy coming in from this time forth and for evermore.’ Then they, too, were converted to Judaism. He sent for him no more.

Zohar (3 266b)  R. Abba further discoursed on the verse: “The Lord shall keep thy going out and thy coming in from this time forth and for evermore” (Ps. CXXI, 8). He said: ‘That God shall keep thy going forth we understand; but what need is there to say, “thy coming in”? For when a man goes into his house he is in no danger? What it means, however, is that he who affixes the holy sign to his house with the words of the Holy Name is protected against all danger. The one who dwells at the door of his house accompanies him when he issues forth, and when he returns it proclaims before him: Have a care for the honour of the image of the Holy King-all this on account of the Holy Name which is impressed on his door, so that not only is a man protected in his house, but God protects him both when he goes out and when he comes in, as it is written, “The Lord shall keep thy going out and thy coming in”, etc. But as for the evil spirit that abides between the doorposts, woe to the man who does not know how to guard against it by impressing on the door of his house the Holy Name that it may be with him, for this spirit has three hundred and sixty-five assistants, one for every day of the year, which accuse him above and below, trying to mislead him by day and troubling his dreams by night. When he goes out they accuse him; when he comes in they place their hands on his shoulders and say: Woe to So-and-so who has thrown off the control of his Master, woe to him in this world and in the world to come! Therefore the sons of the true faith should be stamped throughout with the impress of their Master to scare away all the sides of the “evil species”, that they may be protected in this world and the next.’


12 comments :

  1. He believed clear argumentation was part of Torah mesora.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Either ditch all the codes after the gemara, or allow rishonim to determine halacha.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Why does rav emden reject both the moreh nevuchim, and to some Degree the zohar?

    ReplyDelete
  4. from Shomer Eminum -translated on the link below.


    So unifying the Sefiros is the purpose of creation...?


    I had a correspondence with R' Norman Lamm z'l, back when he was still the active head of YU. He claimed that all the Kabbalists, including the Gra, rav Haim Vollozhiner etc held that the Sefiros are God, ie the God in the Torah.
    This is also the view of Chassidus.


    No, look below, and Rav Irgas is saying that we pray to God #1 to unify the sefiros (god # 1-10? or is it god[s] 2-11?)


    So how many gods are there? DO we need the Kabbalah and unreason to teach us the mystery that actually the torah lied when it said there is only 1 Deity?



    https://translatedseforim.wordpress.com/2016/02/09/shomer-emunim-b12-b13/




    "So


    now that I explained to you the Ari, Z”LHH’s perspective on the purpose


    of creation, that it was so that Hashem could bestow goodness on


    something other than Himself, we can understand what our task is, and


    how we relate to the Infinite. For our intentions are to complete and to


    unify the Sefiros through our actions and Mitzvos or through prayers,


    so that they {the Sefiros} will be prepared to receive His light and His


    influence. THAT’S what’s called serving the Infinite. Because even


    though He, Y.S., receives no benefit from our efforts, never the less,


    since His entire objective is to bestow goodness upon something other


    than Himself, therefore, by connecting and unifying all of His


    attributes, and all of the Sefiros through Torah, Mitzvos and prayer, we


    cause all of those levels to become complete and prepared to receive


    His influence and His goodness. And THAT’S called serving Hashem because


    Hashem is not served by our Tfilos and Mitzvos, but by bringing close


    all of the attributes, and all of the Sefiros to Him. In other words,


    through this {our Tfilos and Mitzvos}, all of the higher levels become


    prepared to receive His influence, and then share that influence with


    the lower levels. THAT is the ultimate purpose of creation, which is to


    benefit, as we discussed earlier. R’ [Moshe Cordevero] already wrote


    about this in length, in his Sefer Alimah, in the section called Ayin


    Kol – The All-Seeing Eye, Tamar 2, Chapters 2 and 18. Refer there for


    more research.














    [So


    he’s adding another dimension to the discussion which is quite


    fascinating, because he’s saying that our Tfilah doesn’t change Hashem.


    Our Tfilos and our Avodah changes the Sefiros, which can receive the


    infinite benefit from Hashem, and then pass that benefit along to us.]"

    ReplyDelete
  5. more from shomer emunim


    So a few chapters ago, he was saying the sefiros are disunited entities, which we pray for them to be unified. Now he says (see below) the are forever connected (or at least never separated) from Him, (add chas veshalom!).


    it is like the avodah zarah of the medusa with many arms - the grotesque idoaltry of the kabbalists!



    https://translatedseforim.wordpress.com/2016/01/17/shomer-emunim-b4-b5-2/










    "That’s why we can use light as a metaphor
    for the Sefiros, because they {the Sefiros} are coming out and being
    emanated from a G-dly source of light and are never separated from Him,
    Chas Veshalom. The emanated is forever connected to its source and the
    power of the Emanator is always within the emanated."

    ReplyDelete
  6. yep
    more emes

    ReplyDelete
  7. https://www.artscroll.com/Books/9781879016132.html






    If You Were G-d








    By Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan (Author)








    the author makes the dangerous case, asking people if they could make a better world if they were G-d! This is a very arrogant and unpardonable display of "free thinking" - in fact it is the area of apikorsim to suggets how they can be better or do better


    here is an example, by Roger Waters - who takes the liberty of provinding a teshuva to Rabbis kaplan's sh'eila



    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHLi4n4W43M

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Meisit, the Nachash, the Satan, and the yetzer hara cannot argue purely through sechel and rationality, so they use tricks - fallacies (eg fallacy of authority, of "un"broken tradition etc), emotion, fear, threats to msilead the masses into avodah zarah, arayos, and kefirah.

    ReplyDelete
  9. So according to R' Kaplan, G-d has/had restrictions , could not reveal Himself, to the people! This, despite the Torah saying that He did reveal Himself, through miracles, through Torah, to neviim, and the oft said statement in Nach that there is Eolkim in Israel; the recognition of Pharoah's magiains of Etzbah Elokim Hi...



    https://aish.com/48970646/

    "Your Restrictions:

    Under no circumstances are the natives of this island to be aware of your presence.

    This supersedes all other considerations.

    The cultural shock caused by your revealing yourself would disrupt the entire fabric of the island culture. It would cause much suffering and more than offset any good that you could possibly accomplish.

    The natives would be reduced to a state of almost vegetable-like dependence from which they would be unlikely to recover. If they did recover, they might rebel so violently as to eliminate any positive values they might have originally had.

    Therefore, the restrictions that you not reveal yourself must be followed without exception under any circumstances.

    But aside from this restriction, you have a free hand to proceed as humanely or as ruthlessly as you see fit.

    In short, you have the opportunity to play God.

    What would you do?"

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow we are fortunate having you available to tell us what is true since none of us has your insight!

    ReplyDelete
  11. is it still Adar?

    ReplyDelete

ANONYMOUS COMMENTS WILL NOT BE POSTED!
please use either your real name or a pseudonym.