It is not clear from the discussion what RSF actually said. Is it regarding Kabablah, or what? In any case, how do you draw the line between explanations and Mesorah?
They posted there a snippet of two lines of manuscript, allegedly from Rabbi Shlomo Fisher, which reads as follows (DT: You can copy and paste the text into your post): ודע עוד, דהמהר"ל אינו מחכמי הקבלה המוסמכים, וכל דבריו דרך סברא בעלמא
I contrast this with Rabbi Yitzchak Hutner's sweeping assertion regarding the Maharal: כל דבריו אינם אלא סתרי תורה בלשון נגלה http://forum.otzar.org/download/file.php?id=59467&sid=20e1b0003bc3a52e9ba8c237d035b6fe
It is not clear from the discussion what RSF actually said. Is it regarding Kabablah, or what?
ReplyDeleteIn any case, how do you draw the line between explanations and Mesorah?
They posted there a snippet of two lines of manuscript, allegedly from Rabbi Shlomo Fisher, which reads as follows (DT: You can copy and paste the text into your post):
ReplyDeleteודע עוד, דהמהר"ל אינו מחכמי הקבלה המוסמכים, וכל דבריו דרך סברא בעלמא
I contrast this with Rabbi Yitzchak Hutner's sweeping assertion regarding the Maharal:
כל דבריו אינם אלא סתרי תורה בלשון נגלה
http://forum.otzar.org/download/file.php?id=59467&sid=20e1b0003bc3a52e9ba8c237d035b6fe