Rav Yaakov Hillel](Faith
and Folly: The occult in Torah perspective)
cogently denounces misguided "spiritual" activities. He relates
the following chassidic story. "A poor chasid traveling through the woods
met an old man. The old man gave the chasid a coin and told him to use it to
buy merchandise. In the weeks after returning home, the chasid found his meager
business prospering. He quickly became very wealthy. He went to his Rebbe to
tell him the good news and to give a generous donation to the poor. When the
Rebbe heard the full story he told his chasid that he had to return all his new
wealth to the old man. The Rebbe told him that the old man was someone who had
special powers but they were from the evil spiritual sources. The chasid
listened to his Rebbe's command. He gathered up his newfound wealth and
traveled back into the woods. He found the old man as before and explained why
he was giving back everything. "I'll take back everything as your Rebbe
requested, but I want you to go back to your Rebbe and tell him that the source
of his power is the same as mine". The distraught chasid returned to his
Rebbe and told him the message. The astonished Rebbe concluded regretfully that
he could no longer be a rebbe. He left town and was never heard from
again."
The Bostoner Rebbe, commenting on this story, said that
it is not always easy to distinguish between genuine spirituality which comes
from being close to G‑d and spirituality which draws its power from negative
spiritual energies. Thus spirituality is clearly important for the religious
Jew – but only a spirituality developed through Torah and mitzvos is viewed as
spirituality.
He is under no obligation to return his wealth to the old man. If you win the lottery (secular) , are you forbidden to keep the winnings?
ReplyDeleteIt was only when he was ordered by his Rebbe to give it all back that he became obligated to do so.
ReplyDeleteReminds me of the Michtav MiEliyahu where he says that both Yetzers look the same to the individual. You have to use wisdom to discern which one is Tov and which is Ra.
ReplyDeleteI see your point.
ReplyDeleteBut his Rebbe was "drawing his power from negative spiritual energies," (and admitting that, he resigned from being a rebbe and left town), so was the chasid really obligated to listen to such a person as a "rebbe" ?
ReplyDeletehttps://youtu.be/AGEbed_98CU
ReplyDeleteIf this rebbe didn't know where he was getting his powers from, how can anyone know? I have come across a phenomena of people who are very chareidi but have severe blind spots. For example, I gave a neighbor 200 shekels and am waiting for two weeks now to get back my 50 shekels change. When he borrows chairs I wait endlessly to get them back. Otherwise, wonderful people. So what's going on?
ReplyDelete