April 23, 2006 – Marriage. They reside is Silver Spring, MD.
November 2007- a daughter is born.
March 2008 - Tamar tells Aharon that she is divorcing him.
April 10, 2008 - Tamar takes child along with her from their home in Silver Spring, MD across state lines to Philadelphia, PA, without permission from either a Beis Din or a Court.
September 2008 – Both parties sign joint arbitration agreement to have all issues settled at the Beis Din of Baltimore.
January 2009 – First hearing at the Beis Din of Baltimore.
March 2009 – The Beis Din of Baltimore issues interim custody schedule.
April 2009 - Rabbi Dr. Barry Freundel, Vice President of The Vaad HaRabbonim of Greater Washington, installs secret video recorders in the Mikvah that he founded, to be able to record and view women undressing in the Mikvah.
June 2009 – Civil trial on custody and visitation held in Montgomery County Civil Court. Rabbi Mordechai Shochotovits from the Beis Din of Baltimore demands the parties to dismiss the civil case.
July 2009 – The Montgomery County Civil Court issues a ruling on the custody and visitation dispute. The Beis Din of Baltimore informs the parties that the religious divorce and other issues beside custody and visitation will still be heard at the Beis Din. Neither party asks the Beis Din for another session.
April 13, 2010 – Dr. David Epstein, Tamar’s father, dies of cancer. Dr. Epstein was an active supporter of The Talmudical Yeshiva of Philadelphia (Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky’s Yeshiva.) He volunteered his medical services to the Yeshiva student body and was on call to tend to the care of the students 24/7, said a close friend, Rick Goldfein (Tamar’s טוען(.
April 2010 – Aharon and Tamar are divorced in civil court.
May 2010 – Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky, writes a letter on the stationery of the Talmudical Yeshiva of Philadelphia saying that he is personally acquainted with the facts, and claims that Tamar is an “agunah” who has just suffered the passing of her father after a tragic illness. He writes further, “I appeal to anyone who has any contact with Aharon Friedman to urge him in the strongest of terms of give her a get immediately and to put an end to her suffering.” (The typo is in the original text.)
August 2010 - Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky writes another letter on his personal stationery from the Talmudical Yeshiva of Philadelphia. This is a quote, “To the extent that certain individuals may be advising Aharon to withhold a get, I would ask anyone who knows who these individuals are to do whatever is necessary to impress upon them the importance of assisting Aharon to conduct himself בדרך הישר and to bring this matter to its rightful and proper conclusion with the issuance of a get וכדין כדת“.
December 9, 2010 - Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky writes yet another letter on his personal stationery fromthe Talmudical Yeshiva of Philadelphia. He writes,
“It has been brought to my attention that certain persons may be unclear as to my position on the unfortunate matter of the dissolution of the marriage between Tamar Epstein and Aharon Friedman.
Once and for all, I wish to clarify for all concerned that I am aware that the parties have lived separate and apart for over 21⁄2 years and that a civil divorce was granted almost 8 months ago. I am also aware that in a civil case wherein Aharon Friedman was the plaintiff the civil court ruled on the issues of child support, custody and visitation and those decisions are and have been final in the civil courts.
Under these circumstances Aharon Friedman is and continues to be mechuyav according to halacha to give Tamar Epstein a get and I have so indicated to those who have asked my opinion.
I am aware that a demonstration has been planned and as I wrote previously I encourage anyone who has the ability to convince Aharon Friedman to give a get should do so as soon as possible so as to free Tamar from her status as an agunah.
May all who help in this important mitzvah be blessed
<signed> S. Kamenetsky
All Letters written by Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky between May 2010 - December 2010 were written while the case was still open in and under the jurisdiction of the Baltimore Beis Din.
December 17, 2010 – The Vaad Harabonim of Greater Washington write a public letter stating “First, at this time there is no Bet Din order for Mr. Friedman to give a get. Second, there is no Bet Din statement indicating a refusal to comply with a Bet Din’s order to give a get (a siruv) that exists at this time. Third, the Baltimore Bet Din considers the matter of the get to be part of the original case. If a get is requested from that Bet Din they will then rule on that request.”
December 17, 2010 – Members of the Silver Spring community pen a letter “rebuking” the Vaad Harabonim of Greater Washington and joining Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky in encouraging people to protest. Here is a quote:
“We wish to live in a community wherein interpersonal relations are conducted not only upon the basis of the letter of halakha, but also upon its spirit of empathy, sensitivity and mutual respect.
“Whether or not Mr. Friedman is in violation of Halakha in his withholding of Get from Mr. Epstein, we find his actions to be at odds with the character of the community we wish to have.”
December 19, 2010 - – The Organization for the Resolution of Agunot (ORA) organizes a demonstration in front of Aharon’s home in Silver Spring, MD. ORA is considered a feminist organization not recognized in most Rabbinical circles. (A GET given in response to being publicly embarrassed may be considered coerced and therefore invalid.)
December 23, 2010 – Rabbi Hershel Schechter, Rosh Yeshiva and Rosh Kollel of Yeshiva University,who officially guides ORA, pens a public letter quoting Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky as saying that it is proper to convince Aharon to grant his wife a GET. It is noteworthy to note that Rabbi Hershel Schechter was relying on Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky, notwithstanding that Tamar’s father was an active supporter of Rabbi Kamenetsky’s Yeshiva. The case was still open in and under the jurisdiction of the Beis Din of Baltimore.
June 2011 – A Beis Din headed by Rabbi Aryeh Ralbag, the Posek and Head Kashruth Coordinator of Triangle K, issues Aharon a final warning that they will issue him a SIRUV (order of contempt). This “final” warning was not preceded by any other warnings or invitations to appear in Beis Din.
September 2011 – Aharon is issued a SIRUV (order of contempt) and a LO TZAYIS DEENA (failure to listen to a Beis Din verdict) document by the Beis Din headed by Rabbi Aryeh Ralbag. It is noteworthy to mention that Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky was one of the signatories on the SIRUV and LO TZAYIS DEENA document, even though Tamar’s father was an active supporter of Rabbi Kamenetsky’s Yeshiva.
Rabbi Mordechai Wolmark was also one of the signatories on this document. Tamar’s טוען ,Rabbi Goldfein, was cross examined in Federal court in Trenton, New Jersey on March 23, 2015 regarding Rabbi Mordechai Wolmark signature. This is part of the exchange:
DEFENSE LAWYER. And Rabbi Wolmark was saying if Wolmark's name was on the seruv, that it might scare Mr. Friedman into granting a get. Is that your take on that?
GOLDFEIN. Rabbi Wolmark wrote, Either way is fine. My name might scare him. There are many serious questions about the above document. One question is, how can Rabbi Aryeh Ralbag’s Beis Din issue a LO TZAYIS DEENA (failure to listen to a Beis Din verdict), if no Beis Din ruled that Aharon must give his wife a GET? Secondly, a SIRUV and a LO TZAYIS DEENA is contradictory by nature. A SIRUV is placed when someone refuses to appear in Beis Din. A LO TZAYIS DEENA is for after there was a verdict, the person fails to listen to the verdict.
October 2011 – The Vaad HaRabbonim of Greater Washington declare that Aharon is “in violation of an order of Beis Din and accordingly is now considered halachicaly to have made his wife an agunah,”based primarily on the SIRUV and LO TZAYIS DEENA issued by the the Beis Din headed by Rabbi Aryeh Ralbag. They urge all their synagogues not to give an Aliya to Aharon. The Vaad’s Vice President, Rabbi Dr. Barry Freundel, is one of the signatories. Again the question is, as no Beis Din has ordered Aharon to give his wife a GET, how can they say that he is in violation of a Beis Din verdict?
October 2011- The Jewish community reacts by refusing Aharon access to any shul. This was not following the ruling of the Vaad HaRabbonim of Greater Washington who said that he should not be given an Aliya, but not prevented from coming to shul. Any GET given under such extenuating circumstances may very well be invalid.
January 2012 – Protest by ORA in Brooklyn against Rabbis supporting Aharon.
March-April 2012 - Tamar’s family pays $60,000 to Rabbi Mendel Epstein in order for him to facilitate a beating of Aharon to give a Get. (Such a Get would be invalid.)
July 29, 2012 – Three men hired by Rabbi Mendel Epstein try to beat up Aharon in Philadelphia, PA when he drops off his child at his mother-in-law’s residence.
August 2012 – Rabbi Dr. Barry Freundel, Vice President of The Vaad HaRabbonim of Greater Washington, declares in a correspondence to Aharon’s brother, “We have made our position clear, both on the use of illegal acts to obtain a get and on the refusal to grant a get. We fully stand by both.”
July 2013 – Rabbi Nota Greenblatt clandestinely writes a “heter” for Tamar at the request of and with information from Rabbi Sholom Kamenetsky. In a later letter, Rabbi Sholom Kamenetsky states that his father Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky agrees with the “heter” of Rabbi Nota Greenblatt.
October 2013 – Rabbi Mordechai Wolmark (one of the signatories on the first Siruv and Lo Tzayis Deena) and Rabbi Mendel Epstein arrested by the Federal Bureau of Investigation for beating and forcing Jewish divorces.
December 2013 – Tamar publicly declared “free” without a GET by ORA. The identities of Greenblatt and the Kamenetskys are held in secret. The Beis Din headed by Rabbi Aryeh Ralbag and the Vaad HaRabbonim of Greater Washington do not rescind their respective Siruv and Lo Tzayis Deena documents against Aharon nor do they make a statement regarding Tamar’s status.
October 2014 – Rabbi Dr. Barry Freundel, Vice President of Vaad HaRabbonim of Greater Washington and a signatory on the Vaad’s siruv against Aharon on October 2011, is arrested by the Metropolitan Police Department of the District of Columbia. The charges were that he secretly filmed between April 2009 and October 12, 2014, women undressing in the Mikvah that he founded. Freundel's arrest sparked widespread debate about how Mikvaos should be supervised, administered and protected from predators.
May 15, 2015 – In front of a packed courtroom, Rabbi Dr. Barry Freundel is sentenced by Judge Geoffrey M. Alprin of the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, to six-and-a-half years in Federal prison and fined $13,000.
June 2015 – Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky pens a public letter that he personally had never permitted Tamar to remarry without a GET.
March 2015 – Tamar’s lawyer acknowledges in a Federal Court in New Jersey that Tamar’s family had paid Rabbi Mendel Epstein $60,000. Her lawyer further stated, "Rabbi Wolmark said that Rabbi Epstein could turn up the heat."
July 2015 – The Baltimore Beis Din writes a public letter that as per their knowledge that Tamar has not received a GET, she is not permitted to remarry.
September 24, 2015 – Tamar “marries” Adam P. Fleischer in Memphis, Tennessee. The mesader “kidushin” is Rabbi Nota Greenblatt, which ultimately uncovers Rabbi Greenblatt and the Kamenetskys as the Rabbis who permitted Tamar to remarry. They reside in Philadelphia, PA.
October 2015 – Rabbi Nota Greenblatt says in a phone interview that, “Tamar was permitted by the Rabbis; she got married”, and “he (Aharon) could give a Get to her right now,” acknowledging that a Get has not been given. He further declared, “Leave it to the Rabbonim!”
November 2015 - Letters of protest against the “heter” start pouring in from various prominent Rabbis and Rabbinic Organizations from the United States and Israel.
November 3, 2015 – The Baltimore Beis Din releases another letter saying that Tamar is forbidden to remarry without a GET.
November 12-15, 2015 – Agudath Israel of America annual convention. The slogan was “LEADERSHIP, yourself, your family, your community”. Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky came with a police escort to the convention, to deliver the keynote speech on November 12. There was a strong police presence at the convention. Seemingly, there was a threat of a demonstration against Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky regarding his consent of the “heter”.
November 26, 2015 – Rabbi Nota Greenblatt retracts his “heter”.
November 27, 2015 – Rabbi Nota Greenblatt reaffirms his “heter”.
very good
ReplyDeletehad you made a point of tying in Barry "Epstein" Freundel earlier, the campaign may have been more effective
Are you suggesting that a gadol cannot interfere in the goings on of an active Beit din, even if he's deemed greater than them?
ReplyDeleteI am not suggesting it is clearly wrong. Both sides agreed to accept the Baltimore Beis Di8n
Deletewhat a mix up. this is what happens in a country with too many authorities and batei din. everyone can go shopping.
ReplyDelete