I don't see what the big deal is. He can't get in to speak, and save lives, unless he negotiates with the rabbis. The rabbis are saying that calling the police is their halachic turf. Speak about other things, but not that point. So he did, and when asked about it, he told the truth.
I wish he would have had the guts to ignore the instructions. I'd love one of the rabbis who say it is assur to report a pedophile to attempt a halachic tshuva to back their position. I am convinced that it is a lack of knowlede of Choshen Mishpat. 1. Many poskim permit reporting a physical hit. Why should a perv be less than a fist? 2. Many poskim permit beleiving children and women in cases of nezikin. Rabbenu Gershom, but Rashba disagrees. Machlokes Mechaber and Rema. 3. It is permitted to report those who harm the public. So I've got 3 angles to permit it.
I don't see what the big deal is. He can't get in to speak, and save lives, unless he negotiates with the rabbis. The rabbis are saying that calling the police is their halachic turf. Speak about other things, but not that point. So he did, and when asked about it, he told the truth.
ReplyDeleteWe need to pray that the goyim in this מדינה של לסד will do something to protect Jewish (orthodox) from being abused.
ReplyDeleteThis systematic child abuse and its coverup by rabbis is the modern version of moloch worship.
I wish he would have had the guts to ignore the instructions.
ReplyDeleteI'd love one of the rabbis who say it is assur to report a pedophile to attempt a halachic tshuva to back their position. I am convinced that it is a lack of knowlede of Choshen Mishpat.
1. Many poskim permit reporting a physical hit. Why should a perv be less than a fist?
2. Many poskim permit beleiving children and women in cases of nezikin. Rabbenu Gershom, but Rashba disagrees. Machlokes Mechaber and Rema.
3. It is permitted to report those who harm the public.
So I've got 3 angles to permit it.