This is so old. The video was posted at least as early at 2006.
I can't understand why they decided to throw him out of the room. He was respectfully asking questions. Was RAY unable to refute as the questioner kept asking?
This is a really cut down version. They decided to throw him out, because he wasn't being respectful. He just kept sputtering the same stuff over and over, and wouldn't answer any of the responses that Rav Amnon Yitzhak gave him.
I believe that in the unedited version this went on for like 30-40mins. Quite honestly that isn't he point of of one of RAY's lectures like this. He is there to answer questions people have about Torah observance.
Shouting at a Rav at his own event can hardly be considered respectful. He wasn't asking questions. He was stating his propaganda over and over again.
That a Satmarnic had the Hutzpah to show up and argue with a Yemenite Rav is impressive, I will admit. Especially considering the recent history of Satmar stealing Yemeni children. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KZ9NkYExumg&feature=player_embedded
He wasn't "shouting". And that guy wasn't Satmar. He was asking questions. And for a while RAY was answering. It was, afterall, a Q&A session RAY offered.
And you are mixing up the Satmar rescuing Yemenite children with the Zionists kidnapping their children to make them irreligious (after the Zionists forcibly cutoff all of their payos.)
Good luck to both of them with that one!
ReplyDeleteOr, as Shakespeare once said: A pox on both your houses!
ReplyDeleteThis is so old. The video was posted at least as early at 2006.
ReplyDeleteI can't understand why they decided to throw him out of the room. He was respectfully asking questions. Was RAY unable to refute as the questioner kept asking?
This is a really cut down version. They decided to throw him out, because he wasn't being respectful. He just kept sputtering the same stuff over and over, and wouldn't answer any of the responses that Rav Amnon Yitzhak gave him.
ReplyDeleteI believe that in the unedited version this went on for like 30-40mins. Quite honestly that isn't he point of of one of RAY's lectures like this. He is there to answer questions people have about Torah observance.
He was respectful the entire time. When they ran out of answer to his tough questions, they panicked and physically threw him out.
ReplyDeleteShouting at a Rav at his own event can hardly be considered respectful. He wasn't asking questions. He was stating his propaganda over and over again.
ReplyDeleteThat a Satmarnic had the Hutzpah to show up and argue with a Yemenite Rav is impressive, I will admit. Especially considering the recent history of Satmar stealing Yemeni children.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KZ9NkYExumg&feature=player_embedded
He wasn't "shouting". And that guy wasn't Satmar. He was asking questions. And for a while RAY was answering. It was, afterall, a Q&A session RAY offered.
ReplyDeleteAnd you are mixing up the Satmar rescuing Yemenite children with the Zionists kidnapping their children to make them irreligious (after the Zionists forcibly cutoff all of their payos.)