Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Ignorant Why They Exist

Rambam (Introduction to Mishna): Since the purpose of man is develop knowledge and wisdom why did G d create the majority of people who are not intellectually developed, lacking in cleverness and empty of wisdom and concerned primarily with their lusts. We even see that wise men are held in contempt as well as being few in number? The answer is that these type of people exist for two reasons. The first is to provide support and services to the rare wise person. In fact if everyone sought wisdom and philosophy the world would not function very well and life would soon disappear from the earth…. Furthermore to learn all the skills necessary for society, the lifespan of Mesushalech would not suffice. Even more problematic is that an individual who had to be self sufficient would have no time to study and acquires wisdom. That is why the majority of mankind is needed to preserve and develop society so that the elite will have their material needs supplied. As a result not only will the world continue functioning but wisdom will also flourish… This is in fact the reason why our sages described the intellectually undeveloped masses am haaretz …. The second reason for the existence of those lacking in wisdom is to provide companionship for the small number of wise men… While you might think that this is an insignificant reason, it is in fact much more important than the first. We see that G d even had wicked people populate Israel to create a society and to remove the loneliness of the pious (Shemos 23:29)…

3 comments:

  1. Intellectuals are the stupidest people around. We need ignorant people to keep the lights on and the supermarkets stocked so that the intellectuals can walk around and act like it's all for them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So you are disagreeing with the Rambam or deliberately changing the subject?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well, Rambam is twisting the plain meaning of the verse to satisfy his theory.
    The verse is about driving out the wicked or canaanaites slowly so that the infrastructure doesn't collapse and that wild animals don't take over.
    At that time there were lions, leopards and other big animals that are now in Africa.

    ReplyDelete

ANONYMOUS COMMENTS WILL NOT BE POSTED!
please use either your real name or a pseudonym.